A vinyl rarity from Peter, who has provided the following information and review:
Paul Gonsalves and His All Stars (Riviera XCED 521 149 - also pressed by RCA London with the same catalogue number, but under Riviera's parent company, Barclay).
A1 - I Cover The Waterfront (Green, Heyman) 5:05
A2 - St Louis Blues (WC Handy) 5:50
A3 - Alerado (Will Bill Davis, dedicated to Alexandre Rado) 3:25
A4 - Moon Love (Mack David, Mack Davis, Andre Kostelanetz) 4:50
B1 - Midnight Strole (Anderson) 7:30
B2 - Blues for Marilee (Turney) 2:40
B3 - Sugar Loaf (Anderson) 3:00
B4 - Walkin' (Carpenter) 7:05
Paul Gonsalves, tenor sax
"Cat" Anderson, trumpet
Norris Turney, flute, alto sax
Will Bill Davis (as "Prince Woodyard"), organ
Joe Benjamin, bass
Art Taylor, drums.
Recorded Studio Hoche, Paris, 6 July 1970.
This one is not often seen. Never on CD, and only once on vinyl (Paris and London, 40 years ago).
I doubt anyone would claim this is Paul Gonsalves' - or Cat Anderson's - best work technically speaking. It is from 1970, late in their respective careers, when the years and lifestyles had taken a toll. Apart from the yearning romanticism (with a few outbreaks) of "Waterfront" - Gonsalves' signature tune in his later years - this is not really the place for the smoothness of a Stan Getz, or a Ben Webster in more pacified mood.
However, the playing is adventurous and risk-taking, beyond what you might have expected. I have always liked WIlliam Alonzo Anderson's playing ... not necessarily first and foremost as a high-note specialist atop a famous orchestra at full blast.
And I have always liked Paul Gonsalves too. Again, not necessarily for a particular Newport marathon.
Responding to Gonsalves' lithe sound and impassioned input is a common reaction, it seems, so I hope this upload is popular.
As Humphrey Lyttleton once memorably put it (hardly as a criticism), "by this time Gonsalves' style was like a man sliding around on several banana skins". He certainly slithers, slides, breathes, flutters and is extravagantly expressive on this date - however inconsistent the attack may be in places, and even if he sits out two tracks and only joins the out chorus on another. He seems to get slightly bored playing close to the melody on "Moon Love" after a while, but his two salutes to France are witty and more pertinent on this Paris date than most saxophone quotes!
Alexandre Rado's sleeve note makes most of the unexpected "modernism" on this date, in particular on "Walkin'" (which like "Waterfront", reprises a track from Gonsalves great session "Getting Together!" of a decade before). Justifiably enough. Norris Turney's enterprising "lateral" solo is indeed reminiscent of Eric Dolphy (perhaps surprising from an Ellingtonian) - in fact, it was this reference that first put me on to Dolphy.
But you could go further: the playing of all three horns throughout the date (even on superficially unpromising bossa nova and samba-ish rhythms) is fresh and inspiring, even if there may be some uneven playing, and brittleness in places. Cat Anderson is by no means just an epigone of Louis on "St Louis Blues", there are more daring elements even in that old warhorse (he reserves a more traditional approach, with Bubber-like muting for his original jaunty blues "Midnight Strole").
I have to admit that I have worked on the transfer. Not only that my LP had a lot of crackle, clicks and one big crack across it, but also insofar as I felt the recording was poorly balanced. In particular, the trumpeter was completely swamped by Will Bill Davis' organ on WC Handy's famous standard. If you like swamping by organs, please feel free to ramp up the right channel there. In other places too, left and right channels were poorly balanced (leading to a clash rather than a complement of instruments). My apologies, I did this for musical reasons.
PS: I am not sure the plain text files download from the zip, for reasons I am unclear about. But it doesn't matter - just C and P the above, it's essentially the same!
Paul Gonsalves and His All Stars (Riviera XCED 521 149 - also pressed by RCA London with the same catalogue number, but under Riviera's parent company, Barclay).
A1 - I Cover The Waterfront (Green, Heyman) 5:05
A2 - St Louis Blues (WC Handy) 5:50
A3 - Alerado (Will Bill Davis, dedicated to Alexandre Rado) 3:25
A4 - Moon Love (Mack David, Mack Davis, Andre Kostelanetz) 4:50
B1 - Midnight Strole (Anderson) 7:30
B2 - Blues for Marilee (Turney) 2:40
B3 - Sugar Loaf (Anderson) 3:00
B4 - Walkin' (Carpenter) 7:05
Paul Gonsalves, tenor sax
"Cat" Anderson, trumpet
Norris Turney, flute, alto sax
Will Bill Davis (as "Prince Woodyard"), organ
Joe Benjamin, bass
Art Taylor, drums.
Recorded Studio Hoche, Paris, 6 July 1970.
This one is not often seen. Never on CD, and only once on vinyl (Paris and London, 40 years ago).
I doubt anyone would claim this is Paul Gonsalves' - or Cat Anderson's - best work technically speaking. It is from 1970, late in their respective careers, when the years and lifestyles had taken a toll. Apart from the yearning romanticism (with a few outbreaks) of "Waterfront" - Gonsalves' signature tune in his later years - this is not really the place for the smoothness of a Stan Getz, or a Ben Webster in more pacified mood.
However, the playing is adventurous and risk-taking, beyond what you might have expected. I have always liked WIlliam Alonzo Anderson's playing ... not necessarily first and foremost as a high-note specialist atop a famous orchestra at full blast.
And I have always liked Paul Gonsalves too. Again, not necessarily for a particular Newport marathon.
Responding to Gonsalves' lithe sound and impassioned input is a common reaction, it seems, so I hope this upload is popular.
As Humphrey Lyttleton once memorably put it (hardly as a criticism), "by this time Gonsalves' style was like a man sliding around on several banana skins". He certainly slithers, slides, breathes, flutters and is extravagantly expressive on this date - however inconsistent the attack may be in places, and even if he sits out two tracks and only joins the out chorus on another. He seems to get slightly bored playing close to the melody on "Moon Love" after a while, but his two salutes to France are witty and more pertinent on this Paris date than most saxophone quotes!
Alexandre Rado's sleeve note makes most of the unexpected "modernism" on this date, in particular on "Walkin'" (which like "Waterfront", reprises a track from Gonsalves great session "Getting Together!" of a decade before). Justifiably enough. Norris Turney's enterprising "lateral" solo is indeed reminiscent of Eric Dolphy (perhaps surprising from an Ellingtonian) - in fact, it was this reference that first put me on to Dolphy.
But you could go further: the playing of all three horns throughout the date (even on superficially unpromising bossa nova and samba-ish rhythms) is fresh and inspiring, even if there may be some uneven playing, and brittleness in places. Cat Anderson is by no means just an epigone of Louis on "St Louis Blues", there are more daring elements even in that old warhorse (he reserves a more traditional approach, with Bubber-like muting for his original jaunty blues "Midnight Strole").
I have to admit that I have worked on the transfer. Not only that my LP had a lot of crackle, clicks and one big crack across it, but also insofar as I felt the recording was poorly balanced. In particular, the trumpeter was completely swamped by Will Bill Davis' organ on WC Handy's famous standard. If you like swamping by organs, please feel free to ramp up the right channel there. In other places too, left and right channels were poorly balanced (leading to a clash rather than a complement of instruments). My apologies, I did this for musical reasons.
PS: I am not sure the plain text files download from the zip, for reasons I am unclear about. But it doesn't matter - just C and P the above, it's essentially the same!

https://rapidshare.com/files/2154136906/PGahAS1970.zip
ReplyDeletevinyl>flac + scans
From Peter NOT grumpy!
Man, do you think you could come up with any more reasons NOT to download this one??
ReplyDeleteWhew!!It appears it's just another effort for Europeans to get the last drop of blood out of decaying former jazz greats.
I doubt this will achieve the *coveted* DEEP CLASP!!
Or alternatively as a way of Europeans offering the chance to earn a living to some of the woefully neglected practitioners of the USA's original art form.
ReplyDeleteNew to me. Fantastic!!!
ReplyDeleteMany thanks.
Never seen it, never heard it and I thought that I knew all Paul Gonsalves recordings! It's really strange that a recording made for a company like Barclay has never seen a re-release in one form or another. Anyway I am thrilled to bits, if there is one like that every week or month, what more can you ask. Thanks to both of you (Peter & Grumpy)
ReplyDeletethanks. Actually you are right there is a Dolphy like solo by Gonsalves on "walkin" which is very strange.
ReplyDeleteThanks for this. Anything by Paul is worth checking out. Deep, go easy- it's just a record. They can't all be masterpieces and you can only try your best on the day.
ReplyDeleteThanks for this. Anything by Paul is worth checking out. Deep, go easy- it's just a record. They can't all be masterpieces and you can only try your best on the day.
ReplyDeleteyou can't ever have enough of Gonsalves! so thanks a bunch, I'm over the moon
ReplyDeleteThank you very much Peter
ReplyDeleteGood grief. I wonder what DEEP's surname might be - "DISGRUNTLEMENT"? "LOATHING"? ....
ReplyDelete"DEEP": However deep your beliefs, and troubles, nobody here is force-feeding you, or extorting cash (Euros or dollars) out of you.
But I have noticed you appear to drift around music blogs as if they were cafeterias and/or (thankfully more rarely) china shops where you can make your occasional useful contributions of a few words of scathing resentment.
I'm glad others have found something to appreciate, and enjoy, in these recordings. :)
Many thanks, great stuff.
ReplyDeleteAll the best,
George
Perhaps it's not Gonsalves' best album, but it's another piece of the puzzle. Very rare indeed. So, many thanks Peter.
ReplyDeleteDEEP, if you're going to be negative, why not try being constructive at the same time? ("Gonsalves sounds like he's having an issue with his reed", that sort of thing.) We're all here because we presumably love the music, and even if Gonsalves was on a downward slope when this was recorded, he was entitled to whatever few bucks of royalties he could extract from Barclay. Being a smartass isn't very endearing.
ReplyDeleteEnough of that...props to Peter and Grumpy for allowing each of us to decide if this session earns the DEEP Clasp, whatever that's supposed to be.
Many thanks for this rarity, Peter and grumpy!
ReplyDeleteIf the LP was in poor condition, you have really done a great job with it! Couldn't complain about anything regarding the sound.
As for the music, the participants may have been in their later years, but the Ellington members were a special bunch that always had a lot to offer. Lyttleton was spot on with his remark about Gonsalves by this time sounding like he was "sliding around on several banana skins", but he always rescues the situation and avoids falling! There is a Ben Webster influence at the bottom of Gonsalves's approach, but he took it and developed it into something that was uniquely his own.
Cat Anderson is quite fine here. Norris Turney had joined the Ellington band only the year before and thereby risen from obscurity. With him Ellington started using flute in his palette, but Johnny Hodges's death just two months before this session also meant that Turney got a promoted role as alto saxophonist.
I like Peter's review and agree that this session in parts is more adventurous than one would have expected. Turney's solo on "Walkin'" in particular is a revelation.
The non-horns acquit themselves well too. Interesting to hear Art Taylor with a bunch of Ellingtonians.
This was actually Gonsalves's second album on Riviera. The year before he recorded one with French musicians called "Paul Gonsalves Avec Les Swingers". It is impossibly rare too, but if someone has it, it would be great to see that one in blogland too.